8 mar. 2007
for this blog against sexism day i will actually write a bit about march 8th.
in romania, although it is called "international women's day" and it is faithfully observed, march 8th is celebrated as more of a "mother's day." meaning - with cards, flowers, proclamations of love and respect for "woman as mother." that is good to have, of course... but it's not exactly a women's day (well, in romanian we say "woman's day" anyway)!
one nice part of pre-'89 celebrations for march 8th in romania were the women-only get-togethers that were organized (women would get half a day off from work), which were sometimes repeated throughout the year with so-called "femina" clubs... i don't know too much about those, actually. but it seems like they might've been a good opportunity to meet, have fun and organize - except nobody organized anything in those times (since people had no actual rights and freedoms). today, on the other hand, it's all consumerist and hedonistic like other holidays. definitely not feminist.
so if in north america it seems to be largely ignored, in romania this day exists completely removed from its radical, feminist roots. its history as a day of women's social and political activism is virtually unknown (that indymedia link points to an article i co-wrote last year, and it's the only such romanian piece that i know of). this was the case during "communism," too, though i can't understand why at the time we didn't at least keep the revolutionary discourse, since we were very good at emptying radical discourse of all applied meaning and using it just "for show." it would've been just as well to pretend. but in romanian society the whole message of women's day got watered down to flowers and candy for "the only woman" (that's whom the romanian card with the heart, which is pretty typical, is addressed to). i suppose the main reason must have been that as a "communist" society we had already transcended gender issues - no sex-based discrimination remained and all people were completely equal (actually true in one sense: nobody had any rights, so we were all automatically equal). therefore, the only specifically female condition was that of mother, and the only thing left to do for march 8th was to celebrate (mothers). i think that was the idea. i have a friend who lives in a country that's still communist today, and from what she says this is the official stance as far as women's rights there, too. of course, just as in pre-'89 romania, this is the happy, propaganda-laced facade of the reality that the culture remains patriarchal and misogynistic to its core, with women doing most of the domestic work anyway, sexual and domestic violence a commonplace occurrence (carefully hidden away and kept "in the family"), mistrust and derision of women in positions of power or authority... yeah, these things are the same whether you have female tractor drivers to put on posters or not. (not sure why tractors specifically, but the female tractor driver was the equivalent of a rosie the riveter figure in communist romania.)
for some details, a very good study is "The woman in the communist regime" by Lavinia Betea in the (summer 2006) "What Does Feminism Need?" issue of the Journal for the Study of Religions and Ideologies. (also available online are the book Gender and the (post) "East"/"West" Divide and two papers, "Gender Inequality in Post-socialist Romania" and "Transition, patriarchy and ‘room-service feminism’ in Romania: a critical discourse analysis perspective").the degree to which people were equal and there was no sex-based discrimination whatsoever in communist romania is perhaps best illustrated by the fact that in a society where almost everything was tabu and freedom of speech was absent, the most tabu subject of all was homosexuality, and gay people were actively persecuted. oh, and least we forget, abortion was illegal.
since '89, there's been some progress made towards eliminating direct discrimination, but the culture hasn't changed all that much.
today, however, people like to argue that there's no "gender issues" and that feminism's not needed in romania as a backlash against having had to deal with the "equality" nonsense imposed by the communist regime... and apparently we've transcended gender again, only in a different way this time: no longer pretending to have achieved full "feminist" consciousness, but based on views that are both conservative ("men and women are different, don't you know?!") and supposedly post-feminist ("women have the vote, what else is there to fight for?").
well, i can enumerate lots of gender issues in romania. and people are aware of most of them, it's just that they don't think of them as issues that society can solve. or if they're not aware it's because they can't be bothered to pay attention to the world around them. there's the fact that romania has one of the highest incidences of domestic violence in europe (1/3 of all women are affected), that until 2002 romanian laws didn't incriminate marital rape or domestic violence as a whole, the fact that women in romania earn about 50% of men's income, the rampant, unapologetic misogyny entrenched as the cultural norm, the triple discrimination faced by roma women, the poor quality of reproductive health services and general lack of access to adequate sexual education, the more recent gloomy news that under the current proposed law women's retirement pensions will be comparatively much smaller than men's, or the fact that sexual harassment is a huge problem in romania but most people blame the victims entirely and don't even know there is a law against it (the law has never been implemented)... or the fact that the legalization of prostitution is being considered by the government, but purely for profit - in order to be able to better exploit prostitutes - while the problem of human traffic is one of the most serious social issues, affecting ever increasing numbers of girls and women all over romania. and that would be just the tip of the iceberg.
the degree to which sexism is not a problem in romania today is perhaps best illustrated by the fact that a couple of years ago the romanian edition of playboy published an article on "how to beat up your wife without leaving traces." (it was an april fools joke, though! obviously. another joke: an "anticonsumerist" site made last year by a couple of dudes who like to think they're hip, cool and progressive is called "dick fashion" and features an illustrated manual with suggestions for when to wear the "dick fashion" tshirts that they sell, and one of these situations is "when you go out and rape.")
so is there a need for feminism in romania? as the ladyfest romania flyer says:
to the "post-feminists," i can't respond any more eloquently than alix olson does to some guy who once told her "i don't get a lot of your feminists references, 'cause we don't have sexism in our country":
to me, for march 8th, the celebration should be all about awareness and learning from the struggles and ideas of various women. around '98 i made this list of some excellent women/feminists, and i still quite like it... but i'd add to it many others.
instead of listing names, though, here's a few of my favorite feminist pieces i saw this past year, in no particular order:
- "Time to Shoot 'Political Corectness' in the Head" by ilyka and "The Greatest Cliché: The Unexamined Propaganda of 'Political Correctness'" by Kai Chang
- "To Review" by piny (about reclaiming slurs) [& "loose woman" by sandra cisneros]
- "Women of Color Morphing into Oppressor Status" and "The Women the World Requires" by brownfemipower
- "Illiniwek fans missed the Indians for the 'Chief'" by Susan Joy Harjo
- “The Untold Story of The Iroquois Influence On Early Feminists” by Sally Roesch Wagner
- "Reconciling Misogyny in Romance Part 1: Sex Sex Sex" and "Extra Extra! Stupid Gender Stereotypes Are Still Alive and Kicking!" by Candy
- "State of the Union: Hot Chicks Get Naked!!!" and "Those Maligned Peta Ads" (bonus: "The State of the Movement" by Gary Francione)
- "getting to the core principles of veganism" by vegankid
- "Planting the future" (about Wangari Maathai's environmental activism in Kenya) and "The day the women went on strike" (about a 1975 national women's strike in Iceland) in The Guardian
- "Pro-choice for Life" by Shark-Fu
- “Fourth arm of the state. Romania's press becomes a willing partner in prejudice” by Valeriu Nicolae
- "Nationalism", "Medicine and Women’s Bodies", "the personal IS political" and "Social Constructionism" by Thinking Girl
and two great posters:













4 comentarii:
wonderful! thank you for the interesting peek into women's stauts and the status of feminism in Romania. We've still got a long way to go for women's rights, but it helps to know that so many voices are being raised in support of gender equality.
stiu ca tuna e numa' una, dar iti multumesc oricum pentru urarea de multi ani. si tie la fel.
2na
I have just discovered your blog. Where are you!? We need you here, in the country, because you are absolutely right and already aware!!!
I feel many times like speaking alone...I don't say always because I am a very optimistic feminist and I know a few others...
Toate aceste cuvinte trebuie spuse in romaneste,sa le auda si ceilalti (si celelalte).
Multumesc pentru lista; demult voiam sa alcatuiesc una dar...
Gabi
salut, gabi. da... vezi si ladyfest romania!
Trimiteți un comentariu