feminism, the eternal mystery
gary francione of The Abolitionist Approach has thoughts on "Postmodern Feminism and Animal Welfare": he argues that the two are essentially the same type of thing and elaborates the ways in which this is a perfect parallel. in the process, he proves that in spite of his usual thoughtfulness and dedication to justice work he just doesn't know enough about feminist movement and ideas. to a certain extent, he did this in the past with the subject of rape... but i think in this case he's really blundered: because he was irritated by an argument that reminded him of animal welfarist arguments, he seems to have abandoned all care for nuance and faithfulness to reality. his point here, in a nutshell, is that someone needs to fight for the rights of those without voice, which includes animals and those poor women exploited by... porn. and i just have to say - WHAT? why is this needed? of course, to a certain extent all social justice work is the struggle to promote the rights of the disenfranchised. and i for one totally agree that certain kinds of feminism ("choice" feminism, "i-feminism," strictly "pro-sex" feminism, liberal feminism) can be pretty frivolous and self-centered, and mainly the domain of privileged women who just want a piece of the (patriarchal) pie, about maintaining the status quo more than anything. but... that's not really francione's point here. in this case, he focuses on porn. and as he elaborates this parallel between animal welfarists and non-anti-porn feminists, his point becomes essentially that just like animals, women who are exploited (by porn) cannot have a voice, so others must step in to take over and order their lives for maximum "justice." i dunno... he does realize that women DO have their own voices, i hope?! that's why there's even a debate on this subject.
first of all, a small observation that i think says a lot about the inaccuracies in francione's argument: the postmodern feminists would never call anyone "patriarchal" -- actually, the postmodernists have an allergy to the term "patriarchal," which is a marked second-wave/radical concept. this, by the way, is one of the many reasons why i also think "postmodernism" is of no use at all when it comes to working for social justice...
but regarding the feminist position on porn, francione hasn't even understood the two "camps" very well. postmodernism hasn't got much to do with this issue... and the camps aren't split along whether commodification of women is inherently bad as he says; any true feminist should have a problem with injustice towards women in general, with the normalization of the female body as nothing more than a sexual receptacle, an object to be used by men -- francione comments about this himself when he singles out rape as an agreed-upon example of injustice. and no, to clarify, peta as an organization is not "feminist" at all, not even the postmodern kind... they use a "post-feminist" rhetoric (we've already solved gender issues, women are already powerful and sexism is not a problem), which is pure bullshit.
rather, the feminist disagreement around "pornstitution" is whether all sex work is "inherently exploitative" (based on different definitions) and women can/should have any agency at all as sex workers. i, for one, am somewhere in between the two poles: i am completely for talking about "pornstitution" as exploitation and violence against women in this society, but at the same time i'm also completely for us, as a society, doing our best to make the lives of sex workers better, through no longer penalizing them instead of those who profit from their work (pimps, traffickers, clients, the police), through unionization, through measures that would benefit them in significant ways -- everything from health care to exit services... for giving women more and better options to choose from. for making homes and streets and communities safer for girls and women (and boys and men). and not least of all changing traditional attitudes towards male/female sexuality. but to me, the important thing is to provide help and needed resources to people who need them most; to listen to them; and to address the problems, in concrete ways, not just some abstract concept of "sexual services for money" which is supposed to be inherently something or other...
the big problem with francione's argument, and with some of what "anti-porn" feminists argue, is that it essentially strips away any agency that a whole lot of women might want or need in their current situations. which is bad, however you look at it. and it's not promoting justice.
and, dear god, this part: "This style of discourse reflects the tactics of the reactionary right. Any dissent is automatically demonized and attempts at reasoned discussion are rejected in favor of slogans and other empty rhetoric that do nothing except maintain the dominant ideology of exploitation." really made me laugh. has francione ever seen any feminist debate on porn? has he looked at how feminists who are categorically anti-porn discuss this subject? because what he says about the "postmodern" feminist discourse is just empty words used to draw the conclusion he wants: that you're either "anti-porn" or reactionary. in fact, those exact words can be used to describe a lot of the "anti-porn" discourse and attitudes; i have experienced this very dynamic at least once on my own skin (to a quite painful degree that truly took me by surprise - and i consider myself quite jaded on this topic... -- read that i blame the patriarchy thread i referenced and you'll see what i'm talking about).
one point of francione's is that, apparently, this thing he calls postmodern feminism "...rejects making any negative normative judgments about these exploitative institutions or how they affect women in lower socio-economic classes who do not have the privileges of the postmodern feminists, who are, by and large, white, middle-class, and well-educated"... well...
REALLY?
it's actually the other way around. the majority of the categorically "anti-porn" are privileged, white, economically well-off feminists who whenever they run into the problem that opposing and condemning sex work 100% means an antagonistic position towards sex workers (and this happens constantly, of course), prefer to retreat in patronizing "false consciousness" feminist discourse (even the most well-meaning ones to whom such discourse is usually distasteful) than to address the issue at some practical level. than to deign to really support, in concrete ways, those women who need support. because... they just know better. and never mind that all of us participate in the system to one degree or another, and perpetuate this patriarchy which hurts all women (and men) in a mirriad ways -- somehow sex workers are guiltier than all of the rest of us put together, as well as less conscious (they have to be, they're whores). it's amazing to me that the most obvious flaw in this discourse is so invisible to so many who declare themselves feminist-ier and more anti-patriarchal than thou... the system relies on such attitudes towards "the whores" out there: as a feminist who agrees, you're doing nothing to fight the problem at its roots. radical change needs to entail a different vision of sex and what "sex work" might mean... together with a dedication to ending all economic exploitation and violence towards all women. not just "pornstitution" as we know it.
along these lines, and because i wanted to give a link to it anyway, see:
"A small post" @ Women of Color Blog
(i think it's enough said - if that doesn't stop and make you think, then i don't know... nothing will, probably.)
there's also this (a similar experience is what first made me struggle with and begin to distance myself from a classical "anti-porn" stance of "poor sex workers, how can they bear to do something so demeaning, why don't they realize how exploited they are?!"):
(thanks h.)
but my two old standby quotes on this topic serve quite well too:
"Because of this ["whore"] stigma, which keeps many women from freely exploring, experiencing, and naming their own sexuality lest they be called whore, many critics isolate prostitution from other situations in which women are objectified or their labor exploited, and assume both that any problems associated with prostitution are unique and that the existence of prostitution is the root cause of patriarchal and capitalist objectification, economic exploitation, and violence against all women. From a sex workers' rights point of view, it is the laws against prostitution and the stigma imposed on sex work that provoke and permit violence against prostitutes, and ensure poor working conditions and the inability of many sex workers to move on to other kinds of work without lying about their experience."
-- Priscilla Alexander
"Anti-porn arguments bore me. Such accounts get in bed with right-wingers, infantilize women, condescend to sex workers, refuse to critically consider porn as a social practice, and prescribe what gets to count as "healthy" sexuality (usually vanilla, reproductive heteronormativity). Yawn. But sometimes, it’s true, as a critical theorist, pro-sex politics also bore me. They sometimes (not always, sometimes) feel limited, especially when what counts as politics is just about fucking. And because I’m a cranky girl, I worry about the very real potential for flattening all those uneven social relations and their histories into a spread-around lack of mind-blowing sex. […]If we meaningfully consider sex and sexuality – especially in its regulation and criminalization — in a dialectic with ideologies of race, gender, nation, capitalism, and material relations, the rhetorical hard-sell of personalized liberation falls flat."if francione, or any adamantly "anti-porn" feminist, can talk about other industries/exploitation of (women's) work in the same way they approach the sex industry and exploitation of sex workers -- it they will oppose, say, efforts to better conditions and unionization for sweatshop workers -- then ok, i'll just accept that they wish to opt out of society entirely because they feel any efforts to improve the lives of people caught in the system in one way or another only serves to legitimize the bad institutions. and that's ok. at least it's self-consistent, ethically. but in the meantime, this "inherent exploitation" rhetoric focused exclusively on porn is simply about slut-shaming and -blaming. on top of ignoring the larger picture of women's economic exploitation! there's really no excuse. personally, i think what we need to "be" as feminists is not just "anti-porn" (that's useless) -- rather, let's agree to be against violence, coercion, rape, trafficking, violation of autonomy, intimidation, exploitation, objectification, dehumanization, racism, etc. (all of which does apply to "pornstitution"), and let's work on bringing about change, full recognition and observance of human rights. to me, the problem is not that women are exploited sexually and therefore there's misogyny, the problem is that there's misogyny (and classism and racism) and therefore women are exploited sexually and non-sexually. the parallel as far as animals are concerned is to oppose violence/killing/cruelty/commodification, etc., and aim to end all use and achieve animal rights. it's not that animals are killed for food and therefore animals don't have rights, it's that we're speciist and therefore we kill animals for food and otherwise hurt and exploit them.
-- Mimi Nguyen
i do wish people who care about these things, activists in general, didn't construct their ideologies around abstract holier than thou-ism so much.
especially feminists.










3 comentarii:
Hi! Since you've directed me here to continue this conversation, is it ok if I respond to your quote from there?
"but my short answer would be that i think that there’s absolutely a difference between “naked activism” and “sexist naked activism”. this is not about nudity at all but about misogyny (and other unethical stances). in peta’s case, i think it’s particularly problematic that they are always not just relying on blatantly misogynistic imagery but actually literally encouraging the dehumanization of women. that’s the whole basis of these campaigns of theirs and they’re perfectly in line with the misogyny that drives the “sexual politics of meat.” but even if we just focus on the ways in which they rely on misogynistic images… when they’re referencing porn, of course it’s always the kind of porn that puts women in their place and shows them as vulnerable. even in a commercial in which alicia silverstone is promoting a healthier body through vegetarianism… which would almost make it ok for her to show her naked body as “persuasion”… she’s shown crawling around, filmed from above, looking coy, not exactly… in control. so what’s the point?"
[Initial statement: It's entirely possible that I'm lumping and you're splitting, and they're both valid responses.]
I'm seeing your outline of the reliance on misogynistic imagery above to be a parallel between naked PETA activism and typical porn, not a difference. Women aren't humans, they're "pieces of flesh", "bush", "fresh meat", "dark meat"; they're presented as ready to be split, pounded, devoured; they're filmed in ways that reduce them to submissive, heaving, surgically-modified body parts. Heck, there are even porn site (or videos, or something; I didn't look too closely) called "Meat Holes" and "Fleshbot".
There's probably more, but I'm feeling a bit ill after typing that, and it's late. Gotta get some sleep.
hi! yes, that's basically the sexual politics of meat critique (see carol adams - jill linked to the book in the feministe post). not sure if you are saying i've argued something that is different from this...? but yes, i do think that most of peta's "naked activism" references typical/mainstream porn (and ideas about female sexuality and female bodies), and that this is a problem. if you could be more specific, or if i can answer something, or if you want to continue the "is sex work instrinsically exploitative"/"is naked activism inherently sexist" discussion, just let me know.
btw, an example of a "naked protest" that's not sexist. i mean, of course they can exist, they just have to be based on non-sexist premises.
Trimiteți un comentariu