9.24.2006

on c**ts and other gross stuff

mottos:
- "Sugar and spice and everything nice, that's what little girls are made of."
- "Sometimes, straight men freak out when I talk about my period. I don't talk about it that much... considering how much it happens. I barely mention it. But I guarantee if straight men had a period, you would never hear the end of it. Because, you know, they would never have protection. They would be using old socks. Coffee filters. 'Dude, let me get that sports section when you're done.' Every bachelor apartment would look like a murder scene." - Margaret Cho

recently, i posted one of my favorite poems: "down there" by sandra cisneros. it's her reply to another poem, by john updike, called - yup, you guessed it - "cunts." in it, she proceeds to take apart updike's "bad boy" bravado and machismo, adding in a dose of her own good stuff - namely, a thorough description of menstrual blood. it's one of the funniest and truest things ever written. the poem's pretty long, but the good stuff starts here.

the reason i posted that - together with the title poem from cisneros' book "loose woman" which beautifully reclaims words that are usually thrown at women as insults - was that i'd just gone through a period [no pun intended. really.] in which i saw all of those words used to attack various women, a lot, and i'd had enough. and yes, i was also having my period at the time. and my period is a serious and traumatic thing, physically speaking. my life really revolves around this horrible experience i go through once a month. and yet i don't get to talk about it, because it's... you know, such a gross, shameful, inappropriate subject. as margaret cho says, talking about it freaks guys out.

thing is, maybe it shouldn't matter if it does. i want to talk about it and i will.

i'm NOT ashamed.

when i get my period, if i don't do anything about it i throw up continuously for a whole day. once i have nothing left in my stomach i just retch up bile. i have serious diarrhea. the cramps are so severe that i lose consciousness from the pain (which is a good thing because that way it's "bearable"). i've tried to figure out what's wrong but the only conclusion i've been able to come to is that it's hormonal. nobody really knows, including the doctors i've seen - but there's always the old stand-by advice (including from the doctors) that i should give birth and "it will all sort itself out." of course, because it's neither bearable nor "sortable" i've had to find actual solutions. going on birth control helped a little - it brought the intensity of the cramps down a bit. however, i don't like the idea of the pill, of messing with my hormones in uncontrollable ways - i care about that, even if women are told not to (since worrying about birth control is considered entirely our responsibility, we should do whatever it takes and nevermind the side effects) - so i chose to go off it after a few years (and by the way didn't get my period for about six worry-full months afterwards). other than that, i have to drug myself. (and sodium naproxen is the answer - i got a prescription for it for a while, but that was basically just an overdose. so i overdose. i don't recommend overdosing, but i do recommend this medicine, for anyone with severe menstrual pain who's tried other painkillers and found that they don't work.) let's see, what else?!... doing exercise helps. i've also heard that not consuming dairy is supposed to help, but i haven't found that to be true since i've been vegan for almost 10 years and the problem has stayed the same during this time - not that i should be any yardstick for what happens "normally," i guess. and that's about it.

honestly, i never thought that it could be worse for anyone. i've met many women who suffer quite a bit during their periods, but never anyone who complains of experiences worse than mine. then i discovered that one of my favorite writers, gloria anzaldua, had a much worse history with her menstruation. here's some of it and what the consequences of going through it and hiding it meant throughout her life:
... I think my mother felt OK until I was three months old and blood started appearing on my diaper; i began having a period. She probably thought, "What did I do wrong? ... Oh, it's the result of sin." My mother has a pretty healthy attitude towards sex, except that she's adopted all the standard ideas - that it's dirty, that all men want is your body. ... The kids liked me because I was smart without being obnoxious about it. ... I was extremely sensitive ... I was wide open to everything people were feeling, thinking, sensing. ... I must have been this walking sponge. It was amazing ... I always felt so alien and so strange, because I was bleeding. I had these breasts I wasn't supposed to have, and I was smart. I think I survived by cutting my body off, by blocking certain feelings. I didn't know how bad it was. And I always felt so alien and so strange becasue I bled. The kids didn't know I bled or had breasts. ... My sister suspected something was going on, but the only people who knew were me, my mother, and my father. It became such a good secret that we forgot. ... I couldn't talk about it until ... I was operated on. I went into this pain. I just fell on the floor and went into convulsions. ... I'd have these very high temperatures and then I'd have these very cold flashes. It was the hormones. A year before my operation ... I went to six gynecologists and they wanted to do a hysterectomy. They said my uterus was abnormal - lopsided or whatever; my cervix opening was abnormal, I had the opening of a woman who's had a child. The ovaries were enlarged, especially the left ovary. I had fibroids, scars in the uterus. I started reviewing my past and it just came back to me: "Oh, I had started bleeding at an early age." ... [I had forgotten prior to that o]ff and on during my life. I remember thinking about it when I was a teenager and then forgetting it, but to really talk about it with my mother. ... I called her and told her what the gynecologists said, and she said, "Yes, you started bleeding when you were three months old. The doctor said it was because you were a throwback to the Eskimo." (I have a lot of that very old Indian blood in me.) She told me that she had to make these little girdles so that the kids wouldn't see my breasts, and she had to make sure I had a piece of cloth in my panties in case I bled. Guess we couldn't afford Tampax or Kotex. I remembered it all. I remembered washing the bloody cloths: I'd take them out into this shed, wash them out, and hang them really low on a cactus so nobody would see them. It was painful ... I was a child with no way of protecting myself. Dealing with my sexuality was bad enough, without having to deal with the bleeding! It became a black monster and grew out of all proportion. And the pain was horrendous. Waves of pain would sweep through me. It felt like my insides were going to come out when I threw up. Then there'd be these jabs. When the waves receded I'd be really weak. In my autobiography I describe it as a vulture picking my insides. ... [When that was happening I couldn't really deny it because it was so painful.] But I got used to it and repressed it so that I had no way of gauging when I was hurting, when I was ill. ... Pain was a way of life, my normal way of life. My mother was concerned [about the blood showing, about people finding out], but I wasn't. She was scandalized because at a very early age, I was the only one in the extended family to wear shorts or a bathing suit... No, I don't think I've ever been ashamed to show the body. The shame was something I internalized from my culture, from my mother and my grandmothers. Women have internalized from men the belief that a woman smells and is dirty when she has her period. I had no defense against that belief; I was three months old. When I found myself, it was the beginning of my spirituality, because it was like getting in contact with who I really was, my true self. My body wasn't dirty. ... [I was a part of the big secret, me and my parents,] for the first thirty years of my life. That was the big secret, the big shame. During the operation - it came as an initiation - I discovered that I didn't feel the shame about my body; I feared and hated my body. But it wasn't me; it was something I was taught. ... It was like there were two people in me - one part saying, "This is bad, this is dirty, you're evil. You're bleeding," and the other part saying, "No, that's their perception. I don't feel that way." The two didn't come together until ... I found out that I couldn't possibly have caused the bleeding because I was only three months old. ... So then the guilt split and I didn't feel evil. Part of the reason I helped people by teaching was to compensate, because evil was always tied in with what my mother and sister called "selfishness." I realized that being selfish was being myself, that they called me selfish only because I didn't do what they wanted me to do. But it took me thirty years to realize this. During this time I had terrible guilt and I blamed the body. I thought I was bleeding because I'd done something bad, there was something in me that caused it. [I had taken on more my mother's view of it -] my mother as a personality, no[,] my mother representing the culture's laws, yes. She represents a whole culture: her mother, and my father's mother - all grandmothers, all women. I think it's because women are the law givers, the carriers of tradition. My mother is a pretty amazing woman. She gives lip service to the culture's laws, but it wasn't really her stuff, you know? When you're little, though, you don't distinguish. ...
[Gloria E. Anzaldua, Interviews/Entrevistas, Edited by AnaLouise Keating]

amazing, isn't it?! you don't hear this stuff, nobody talks about it. at most, you hear of "pms" - one term everyone's comfortable with even if they have no idea what it might actually mean (that's PRE-menstrual stress syndrome).

and i don't believe in "pms," not the way it exists in pop culture (let's blame all female idiosyncrasies on it: their periods make women crazy and unreasonable); in fact, i think it's an american invention - certainly in romania it's just starting to get popularized as a concept and used for female bashing and/or for explaining away a variety of other phenomena and behaviors that women go through. when i first got my period, i'd never heard about such a thing as "pms" - menstruation was menstruation, i learned about the physiological basis, what to do (to use old rags as padding, which had to be washed - yes, romanian women didn't yet use commercial pads even as recently as 15 years ago), and that was it. i saw from the very beginning that different women have different experiences with it. but what can't be denied is that menstruation is very much a thing of the body, that it involves hormonal changes, and that it's natural. it can be "bad" or "good" but it's certainly interesting. and NOT GROSS, no matter what everybody says and in spite of the fact that even "sanitary product" ads don't usually show any red colors, let alone real blood.
-> edit for illustrative purposes:
what we get in ads: uh-huh...] [extra-real version, anyone?

] [
the idea that women's bodies are dirty, polluted, unclean - best exemplified by menstruation - is one of the clearest patriarchal manifestations we have. it's been used to relegate women to an inferior status in so many ways throughout history, whether by religious dogma or popular "wisdom" or everything in between.
- read -
thinking girl's "medicine and women's bodies" [one of my favorite blogs lately]
- see -
Museum of Menstruation and Women's Health and Our Bodies Ourselves, of course

and, yeah, like other riot grrrls and feminists before me, i'm reclaiming "cunt" and "bitch" and "slut" all the way. i know that what those terms are, in fact, is a compliment - women who get called those things don't fit people's old-school expectations and fantasies of what a woman should be like, and do, and talk about. or not talk about. mostly, those terms reveal things about the people who use them and their personal issues, which they can't articulate otherwise. so call me dr. cunt, dr. bitch, dr. slut - and let's move on!


this is dedicated to all my fellow cunts. you know who you are :)

19 comentarii:

Anonim spunea...

great post! Wow, that woman with the bleeding at 3 months old - and the scandalous parental coverup! that is an amazing story! thanks for sharing.

for a long time, I hated my period. I didn't have nearly the experiences some women - including yourself - have, but I would get headaches and cramping and bloating, so I felt uncomfortable. then it was better - I went on birth control. but the birth control made me feel not-myself. every feeling I had was heightened the week before my period. then my period was worse when I switched to depo-provera. I went on it for convenience (one shot every three months) AND because my doctor told me my period would stop. It didn't - I bled constantly, without interruption, for about two and a half weeks of every month, the whole time. She told me to try another one, that it would even out. I did. It didn't. (By the way, my boyfriend at the time blamed every fight we had not on him being an asshole, but on my birth control.) After a break from birth control, the IUD came. Much worse cramping, much heavier flow. Not to mention walking around with something inside my uterus. And having to have my cervix opened up to have it inserted, which was basically like having an induced labour contraction. OUCH. Then, a new IUD came along, and my doctor again suggested I change to it because it would make my period go away. After all this fucking around with my period to make it worse, I thought, that sounds good to me. It's been two years. My period still comes, right on schedule, every month.

so, I've had it. I'm having the IUD taken out. During my last pap, the *new* doctor told me it looks like my body is rejecting it anyway. I can't wait to go au naturel. and see what my period is REALLY like.

the nice thing is, most of the cramping and headaches have gone away since I swithced off of using tampons and bought a DIVA CUP! I highly recommend this awesome device! One of the best things about it is that you can see your blood, monitor changes from month to month. I feel like I have finally embraced my blood! yippee!

Anonim spunea...

oh and two more things:

1. have you read any Jacquelyn Zita? she has a great book called Body Talk. It's basically a critique of post-modernism and how it too wants to separate away mind and body, strip bodies of meaning, etc. I think you'd like her work.

2. thanks for the compliment! :)

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

hey. well, i hate my period for obvious reasons, and for me it's a great struggle between staying as "au naturel" as possible (i don't like chemistry-altering substances, of any kind :) ) and not dying from too much pain.

good luck with removing the iud and your period afterwards!

i know the diva cup, we used to sell it at the food co-op i worked at for a while... and we had the brochures and everything... well i'm not sure if it was divacup(tm) - maybe it was the keeper... the concept seems pretty good (if your flow is not too heavy, i guess). but i must say i was never tempted to try it because for me the idea of introducing anything foreign in my body during my period, when i go through this horrible stuff and feel like my insides are being torn apart, just doesn't sound too comfy. i don't use tampons, by the way - i did for a while and it made my periods doubly hellish. i could maybe see myself using the diva cup towards the end of my period, when the pain goes away, but only then...

yes, i think i read some queer theory by jacquelyn zita, but i don't remember what, very well - i'll have to check out "body talk", thanks for the suggestion, it does sound like something i'd be into!

and you're welcome, all of your latest posts have been amazing and amazingly useful, for real. :)

Anonim spunea...

I had noo idea that it can be THAT horrible. Women SHOULD get some days off from work.. But that would probably make them feel embarrassed.

Maslina Si Cartoful spunea...

emberassed about what? its just a body function... does going to the bathroom emberass you? I think you totally miss the point of this post m'dear

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

but that's just it, marius is right - women *are* embarassed by their periods and hesitate to talk about them, just like men are when it comes to hearing about them. that's part of what i was getting at with the post... i personally don't think that women in general need or would want to get days off when they're on their period: after all, some women barely even notice when they get theirs. it depends. i do think that when it *is* debilitating it should be viewed as a legitimate health issue - not that menstruation in general should be medicalized, mind you, not at all! but as far as i'm concerned, i would like to feel free to at least talk about it in a matter-of-fact way to anyone, male or female, and not be ashamed because it's a "woman's thing" or have to use stupid euphemisms to refer to it or whatnot. it *is* a bodily function - but in very different ways from say urinating; there's so much more involved, it's so complicated. i'd say it's a bodily function in the sense that it is physical and natural and completely non-"shameful." it just is.

Maslina Si Cartoful spunea...

heheh... well in that sense I am a woman of the future... I have never been ashamed to talk about my period... considering the AMOUNT that flows... not that I don't know women who would just die to talk about it... and I do agree that there is so much more involved... and frankly that's how I get through my periods... just thinking its another function of my body that I have to wipe, coddle, and keep from falling off... and what pisses me off even more is that I got my period at 11 if you remember in fifth grade... not only did I have boobs, I was on my period... and I do have an emberassing story about periods in fifth grade... involves a chair and a period... you do the math... and sadly you do not want me to start talking about periods... you will hear too much information and too much bitterness

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

yes i do. :)

Maslina Si Cartoful spunea...

lol... ok than what do you want to know?

yours truly

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

um... i dunno. whatever you want to share, i guess? :P

Maslina Si Cartoful spunea...

heheheh better not... its ranting about certain things i hate about having a period... its not intellectual talk... cuz frankly when it comes down to talking about periods, most of the talk isn't intellectual with deep meaning, it is what it is... you bleed you wipe and move on...

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

... but my point is that us treating it like an absolutely normal thing - talking about it or not as we see fit, just never being "embarassed" - might bypass the ranting and hating altogether. basically, i need some approach that will do that for me. as for it not being high brow or deep... i don't see that as a problem at all. :)

Maslina Si Cartoful spunea...

you know what i think its annoying actually? the fact that i can't just write this period thing off as another maybe private thing i have to worry about... i mean yeah from time to time i have to talk about it cuz its such a pain in the ass... but this is another woman's bodily function that criticized to bits. Obviously it has to be talked about but its annoying that as a woman I can't seem to have a bowel movement with out it being watched, talked about, sexified, made to smell better etc.

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

yes, and that is exactly it! the problem is that the way things are now, if you have a female body everyone and their grandmother - except for you - gets to somehow control and judge it and all that has to do with it. on so many levels:
* our bodies are gross in their natural state so we need to do all kinds of things to them to make them look and feel a certain way
* "women's problems" like menstruation are shameful and must not be spoken of in mixed company, and even when mentioned in passing must be called something else so as to not embarrass anyone
* our health is "women's health" which is a hushed-up and obscure thing quite different from regular health, aka men's health; we don't need to be knowledgeable about our own bodies and shouldn't talk about physiological matters (it's inappropriate and unladylike)
* women are expected to be proper "ladies", aka removed from crass physical stuff
* on the other hand, all women's bodies should be ready for public scrutiny at all times, they are synonymous with sex, and women's defining roles are biological, as mothers or sex partners to men

and so on and so forth.

this is what sucks. and this is why i want to just be able to talk about my body and health and women's bodies and health in general in a straightforward manner, to bypass, as i was saying, all the stuff imposed on me, all the norms and bullshit. of course, the real issue is that in lots of cases women don't have a personal choice: with doctors, with companies and the advertising industry drilling into our collective brains (of both men and women) what women should look like as well as the already existing cultural norms and pressures along those lines, with various institutions like the church and state falling all over each other to better control what we do with our bodies and how... because of course we couldn't possibly do it ourselves, that would be quite dangerous!

at the core of it all is this male and even female phobia of women's bodies, of their functions - that's why they must be constantly controlled and overseen by outside forces.

i mean, really, what century do we live in?

Maslina Si Cartoful spunea...

oh i was never under the impression that we have come THAT far in our "evolved" society... we are still a bunch of monkies throwing our poop around and pursing our lips or just beating our chest
at least the actual monkies don't pretend to be anybody but who they are... we live in a world where nothing is what it seems

Jennifer spunea...

Left to its normal devices, I also have very severe menstrual cramping. It would not be an exaggeration to say it feels like there is a knife in my stomach.

Two solutions I have found (apart from taking the pill to eliminate menstrual periods altogether) are

1. To take a mild diuretic a day (or two) before the period, in order to empty the bowel as much as possible. I am surprised how far this goes toward alleviating cramping.

2. On the first day of the period, obliterate myself by drinking a bottle of wine. (Alcohol seems to release the tension in the gut region, improving blood flow, whilst somehow reducing the force of the hormones in the bloodstream.)

Bori spunea...

thanks for sending the link to this older post ... one of the things i have found interesting was that you too encountered the same sort of reaction to menstrual cramps from the medical profession as i have. dare i ask whether it was members of the romanian medical profession? i saw three doctors, two in romania and one in the uk, and all said my sudden switch to very painful menstruation, incontrollable diarrhea, cold sweat and bordering on losing consciousness was just hormonal, nothing to worry about. one romanian doctor said i should have babies and it will all solve everything.

it seems to me that this response to physically taxing menstruation is culturally constructed. i find it interesting that romanian doctors would provide such advice, but not in the uk, for instance. where does it originate from? my mom's periods got worse after birth, same for my very good friend. i'd expect there was some sort of 'medical' explanation, but i haven't encountered any. and then the question is, of course, beyond the whole problem of treating women's physiology as something to hide, hush up, shameful and in general a huge pain in the royal butt, why it is that in romania it is believed that childbirth has the power to solve the pain and physical discomfort part of bleeding ...

Bori spunea...

and to what marius said, but i think got torn apart unfairly: i think it is a good case in point regarding the way in which we as a society don't know how to be grown-ups about menstruation. If women could "legitimately" request sick days for menstrual days, it would raise a serious dilemma: one the hand it would be in support of treating menstruation as a medical issues, where clearly it is not medical, i think. menstruation is not a disease, it is perfectly normal, but varies from person to person. On the other hand, taking sick leave for menstruation - just as sick leave for childcare - can cause workplace discrimination or be yet another cause for avoiding to hire women in particularly demanding jobs. and so it seems to me that marius has pointed to a problem: i for one, even if i was dying of pain, would rather not take the day off, but take a high dosage of ibuprofen and waltz to work.

as for shame, i think it can be problematic and shameful to take days off for menstruation not because we think of menstruation as gross, but because defective workers - including mothers or fathers of young children - are just not tolerated usually in work environments. the ideal worker is fit and completely dedicated to his/her work: the stereotypical he/she (which is actually often a he) does not have bodily issues, a private life as important as work and sickness is exceptional rather than predictable and legitimate.

bujor tavaloiu spunea...

@bori: to answer your question, actually it was doctors in the u.s. who said that, i've never even been to the gynecologist in romania. but it's a pretty accepted idea (both in popular and medical wisdom, it seems), that after giving birth women may suffer less from menstrual cramps. though from what i've seen that's more connected with age than anything (which... yeah), the other sort of explanation is that the nerves in the uterus degenerate with pregnancy and after giving birth never recover completely. see here and here for a bit more info.

in essence, doctors have no idea what causes different levels of primary dysmenorrhea, and that's that - so they'll just give you the usual answers for something to say.

as far as the other points you've made, i agree with you mostly: especially that i don't think as a rule women should get "sick days" for their periods or anything that would medicalize menstruation... it's not an illness. it's the same point i made above, and others too. however, since i do think in some cases (like mine) there's something else going on i think that i should be able to at least talk about it freely, not be ashamed or embarrased to even mention what my "problem" is... that's more my point. and, for me, sometimes even with overdosing on naproxen and doing 1000 other things to minimize the pain, i cannot function normally so i have to take off sick days. i mean, everyone has health issues and it's our right to at the very least not be ashamed that we do, or be able to talk about it when we need to refer to them.